Practicing golf on golf simulator systems is a great privilege that every golfer wants.
If you’re planning to set up a simulator system, you may get the launch monitor and hitting mat in place, but what about the screen? You don’t want to damage your walls!
This is where the impact screen and enclosure comes in!
With so many buying options on the internet, things may get tricky while making a purchase decision, but you can leave that to me.
Without any further ado, let’s discuss the top 5 golf impact screens and enclosures for golf simulators.
Best Overall Golf Impact Screen & Enclosure: SwingBay Golf Simulator Screen & Enclosure
Rain or Shine Golf has been around for many years and is well-known for making premium-quality golf products, but this isn’t the only reason that made me rank the SwingBay Golf Simulator & Enclosure as the winner of the day.
It incorporates a firm assembly framing system with a 3.3″ x 9.8″ solid impact screen to provide you with an unmatched simulator experience.
To optimize the screen for a smooth and crispy projection, it’s made with tightly woven fiber materials which also allow it to take several impact shots at speeds of up to 250 mph.
In addition, the system includes a blackout side and upper walls which are made of commercial-grade polyester material to protect your wall from mishit shots.
Furthermore, it absorbs and blocks external light to reach the impact screen, which otherwise can blur the image and ruin your practice session.
Coming to its price, you may not be satisfied as it’s expensive, but it is made excellently, works well, and is easy to set up, which balances the whole equation.
Watch the SwingBay Golf Simulator & Enclosure in action in this YouTube video by William Rainey:
Pros
✅ Smooth and crisp display
✅ Premium build
✅ It takes impacts of up to 250 mph
✅ Blackout sides and upper walls
✅ Protects impact screen from external light
Cons
❌ Highly-priced
Runner-Up Golf Impact Screen & Enclosure: SIG10 Golf Simulator Enclosure
If you want your golf simulator impact screen to display a 100% image without leaving any white spaces on it, you’re left with no options other than the SIG10 Golf Simulator Enclosure.
The enclosure comes with a 10.1′ x 7.7′ large impact screen that is precisely made to display a 4:3 aspect ratio projection, allowing it to cover up the whole screen without leaving any space behind.
Furthermore, it’s made with tight-knit polyester material that features double-stitched black vinyl edges, making it durable enough to take impact shots of up to 250 mph of speed.
To protect the poles and the wall behind the screen, the enclosure kit includes foam padding that fits the right, left, top, and bottom of your impact screen, allowing you to play without worrying about the surroundings.
In addition, SIG10 has nylon surrounds and side barrier netting to catch stray golf balls that miss the impact screen… although you’re least expected of that!
Overall, it’s a great deal, but there are a few things that you’d want to know before buying one for your simulator setup.
First, it requires a large room, precisely 10.10″ x 8.4″ x 13.7″, for an uninterrupted golfing experience. Second, it takes hours in setting up and also has a considerable price tag, which I personally don’t see as unjustified compared to what it is.
If you can make peace with these factors, you’re good to go!
Pros
✅ 100% on-screen image
✅ Premium build
✅ Includes foam padding
✅ Side barrier netting
✅ It takes impacts of up to 250 mph
Cons
❌ Takes hours to assemble
❌ Requires a large room
Best Customizable Golf Impact Screen & Enclosure: Carl’s Place DIY Golf Simulator Kit With Enclosure
Building a golf simulator enclosure isn’t an easy task, especially when you’re strict about your preferences… I mean nothing’s perfect here and you have to make compromises, but not anymore!
Carl’s Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure comes as a problem solver for those who want everything according to their choice.
It provides you control over the enclosure size, screen material, and other accessories, which makes it highly customizable and hence desirable to many golfers.
To build your DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure, you can start by selecting the impact screen material which offers three options with varying qualities and price tags. These options include:
- Standard golf impact
- Preferred golf impact
- Premium golf impact
Next, you can choose the enclosure size that fits best to your place:
- 7.7’ x 10′
- 7.7′ x 13′
- 8’ x 8′
- 8′ x 10.5′
- 8.5′ x 11.5′
- 9′ x 12′
If none of these enclosure sizes matches your required dimensions, you can also request a custom enclosure by simply using Carl’s Build Your Own Simulator tool.
Lastly, you can add custom accessories to further enhance your golf screen enclosure. These accessories aren’t a must, and you can save a significant amount of money by ignoring them. However, if you’re focused on performance, money shouldn’t be an objection.
The custom accessories include:
- Pipe framing kit
- Foam insert kit
- 8′ net wall extensions (pair)
- Carl’s 4×5 hitting mat
- Carl’s Golf Simulator Turf by Big Moss
Wondering how to assemble the Carl’s Place Enclosure? Watch this YouTube tutorial:
Pros
✅ Allows customization
✅ Multiple impact screen options
✅ Multiple enclosure size options
✅ Custom Accessories
Cons
❌ Gets costly on including more items
❌ Economical choices reduce the overall quality
Best Budget Golf Impact Screen & Enclosure: PerfectBay Golf Simulator Screen Enclosure
For those who are not willing to invest too much in golf impact screens and enclosures but want a setup as good as the SwingBay and SIG10, PerfectBay Golf Simulator Enclosure might be their perfect pick.
With a similar look to the SIG10, this budget golf enclosure also provides some premium features of the top-selling enclosures.
The impact screen is made with triple-layered shockproof polyester to provide extreme durability and is optimized for both 4:3 and 16:9 aspect ratios to give a 100% image without any gaps around the screen.
To increase the authenticity of your golfing experience, the enclosure provides a shading effect on the screen on both sides, top, and bottom, which allows it to display the brightest image possible.
It also includes side netting that catches your missed golf balls to provide additional protection from damage to your surroundings.
One of the best things about PerfectBay is that it is easy to assemble and doesn’t require any special tools for it, making the whole process fast and tireless.
Although it’s a great golf simulator enclosure for its price tag and many golfers may not even notice the difference, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t one.
No matter how good the quality and the experience are, cutting the prices will cost you the quality and performance.
Just keep that in mind before making a decision about it.
Pros
✅ Optimized for both 4:3 & 16:9 aspect ratios
✅ 100% on-screen image
✅ Provides shading effect for clear image
✅ Easy assembly
✅ Economical price
Cons
❌ Not a premium-quality enclosure
How to Select the Right Golf Simulator Enclosure: Buying Guide
Before you spend a handful of dollars on a golf simulator enclosure, I want you to make sure that you’re going for the right choice because it’s not something that you can just replace if it goes wrong.
Don’t know how to do that? Let’s find out through this buying guide.
Screen Size
First, you need to have a clear idea of the available space that you have to put in your golf simulator enclosure. Based on that, you’ll have to choose your impact screen.
Also, you need to determine the aspect ratio of your impact screen because getting it wrong can be trouble for you.
If you want a 4:3 aspect ratio, a square screen will be your right choice. But for a 16:9 wide-angle display, you must consider buying a rectangular-shaped impact screen.
Enclosure
The enclosure is essential for blocking the ambient light in the room from blurring the image on the impact screen and preventing damage to the walls from the golf balls.
However, it adds a considerable amount to your budget. So the best way is to get a DIY enclosure that serves your purpose at a relatively lower cost.
Another way is to set up a side barrier netting without an enclosure, but this will limit your golfing experience and has associated risks.
If you can take it, why not save some dollars?
Quality
Quality matters a lot, and there are some key factors that make a good impact screen.
- It should be smooth enough to carry out a bright, crispy, and vibrant image of the projection.
- It should absorb impacts to reduce ball bounce back and minimize the sound produced on ball striking.
- The manufacturing material should be good enough to make it last for at least 3–5 years.
Budget
Last but not least, the budget decides whether you can buy a specific product or not.
Impact screens and enclosures typically cost a handsome amount of money, but don’t let this fact crumble you because there are budget-friendly options in the market.
I won’t say that they’re cheap, but they cost way less than some top-of-the-line models without compromising too much on the spec sheet.
Consider buying them if you’re low on budget!
Conclusion
Finding the best impact screen and enclosure may have been challenging for you in the beginning, but after you’ve gone through this article, I can confidently say that you’re equipped with all the necessary information to make a purchase.
I have listed the best golf simulator enclosures for every need, but if you’re still uncertain, you can refer to the buying guide.
If you ask me, I’ll recommend you to go with the SwingBay Golf Simulator Screen & Enclosure as it’s the best.
If money is an objection, try the Carl’s Place DIY Golf Simulator Kit With Enclosure as it allows you to build a custom enclosure.
For those who prefer the 16:9 wide-angle display, the PerfectBay Golf Simulator Screen Enclosure won’t leave you wanting!